Pure Sugar, Inc
5 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701 United States
Restaurants, Custom Cakes
Closed now
About
Established on Long Island, NY, Pure Sugar Inc is a beloved local business famous for crafting creative and unique cakes, pastries, desserts, and sweet treats. Whether you're craving something decadent or need a custom creation for your special event, Pure Sugar Inc has got you covered. Operated by renowned Pastry Chef Michael Guasta, our bakery takes pride in making your dessert dreams come true, no matter how simple or elaborate your vision may be. With a focus on personalization and thinking outside the box, we are the name to know and trust when it comes to making your desserts the highlight of your event!
Sort By:
Featured
Megan McQueeney on The Knot
5 days ago
06/03/2023, 04:51 AM
Chef Mike was pleasure to work with and made us beautiful and delicious cake. He really cared about making sure that our cake was something different and exciting while also catering to our specific tastes. I can't wait for the next occasion to order another one of his cakes.
Doris Hughes Jebali on Facebook
3 months ago
02/24/2023, 19:48 PM
After he created an awesome cake for my son’s birthday, I went back to Michael at Pure Sugar to order a custom cake for party my Union’s local threw for our members. The cake was gorgeous, all night long people took pictures of the cake. In addition to being beautiful, it was absolutely delicious. Many guests commented that the cake tasted even better than it looked. Pure Sugar exceeded our expectations and we will definitely be back for more!!!
Gena Fazio Palmer on Facebook
a year ago
04/21/2022, 16:49 PM
Beautiful products, every order is just perfect. Mike gives great guidance and suggestions which turn out better than you hoped for. Highly recommend this shop. Everything item is delicious and perfecto!
Shop local.
Alyssa Dorfman on Facebook
a year ago
04/11/2022, 20:56 PM
We had the most stunning cake made for my son’s Baptism! It tasted just as good as it looked. We had so many options he was willing to make exactly what we wanted but better! There is a lot of talent hiding inside that little bakery would recommend to anyone!
Gab Rielle on Facebook
a year ago
02/27/2022, 18:48 PM
Mike was an absolute pleasure to work with from start to finish! My husband & I had the pleasure to have two wedding cakes made by him- one for our covid-friendly 50 person celebration and then our large wedding reception over a year later. We had a private tasting with him, where he not only listened to my thoughts and ideas, but contributed to my vision to make the cakes even more amazing. His flavors and combinations are unique and absolutely delicious. He truly blew us away with our larger cake and made custom pillars to incorporate the style I had envisioned! I truly recommend Mike and visiting Pure Sugar!
John Schimmel on Facebook
a year ago
02/12/2022, 15:55 PM
They are magical. I gave Michael an idea and he surpassed my wildest dream!!
Kristina Pallas on The Knot
2 years ago
09/15/2021, 14:33 PM
I would absolutely recommend Pure Sugar for your wedding or any other kind of party you may be planning. Chef Mike was great to work with and made everything so much fun! From our cake tasting, to selecting flavors and overall cake design, he really took the time to explain all of the different options we could choose from. The cake tasted phenomenal (and looked beautiful). Chef Mike also worked with us on creating custom designed cookie wedding favors that matched our color scheme. He was even kind enough to attach special thank you tags I had made and delivered the cookies that day along with the cake. Our guests loved them!
Jamie Heaney on Facebook
2 years ago
07/26/2021, 13:18 PM
Mike at Pure Sugar Inc. made such a beautiful cake for our daughter’s baptism party. Everyone talked about how it was too pretty to eat! The flowers and petals were gorgeous and the quilted pattern made it so elegant. It was delicious too. We can’t thank you enough!
Mariella Reiman on Facebook
2 years ago
04/27/2021, 05:38 AM
Absolutely amazing! Mike made exactly what I asked for and more. He takes a vision and makes it come to life. My 5 year old daughter couldn't have been happier! Thank you for a beautiful and delicious cake!